I've wanted to try Everyman for months--the NY Times listed it as one of the best coffee places in NYC, and it happens to be directly across from my dorm. I wandered in to Everyman in the afternoon after a caffeine deprived day--which is never good.
I ordered an americano, not really expecting anything life changing. Needless to say, I was completely wrong--for lack of a better phrase, it rocked my world. I can honestly say that it is hands down the best americano I have had in my life. It is also the best coffee I've had since I left Seattle in August. It was perfect--strong but not bitter, rich flavor, and just the right amount of acidity. I usually put milk and sugar in my coffee, but I drank this straight. Adding stuff to it seemed like blasphemy. That was how sinfully delicious it was.
The place itself is pretty basic--there are lots of tables and chairs, some benches by the wall. It's a nice little haven from the hustle and bustle of Union Square.
To sum up: go. Now. They also play baller music--the barista was rocking out to Aretha when I was there.
Rating: Coffee Nirvana. Conventional rating systems are rendered irrelevant.
Located: E. 13th st between 3rd ave & 4th ave.
